However, Andersons (2013) research shows that even as this digital news sector emerged, longstanding journalistic practices and the large footprint of legacy news institutions such as the Philadelphia Inquirer meant that stasis was more often evident than radical change (p. 159). A closed string, which is the string used in our final database searches, will filter out most irrelevant items (higher precision than the open string, though often at the expense of slightly lower recall). The Inquirer stated some reporting-based facts linked to the papers previous stories about them: That Joe Biden won the state by more than 80,000 votes, that state and county audits affirmed that outcome, and that there is no evidence of any significant fraud. February 2, 2021 The Philadelphia Inquirer announced Tuesday that its Schuylkill Printing Plant has been sold to developer J. Brian O'Neill for $37 million, according to reporting by the. To facilitate comparison between audiences for different outlets, we create easily readable indices for each of these measures of audience demographics. (2006), recall measures the degree to which a search string includes all relevant stories; precision measures the degree to which a search string includes only relevant stories. Life - Inquirer.com Newsrooms need accessible standards about their use of AI to maintain trust with news consumers and ensure accountability of the press. Who am I centering in this story?) for reporters, editors, and producers to consider at different points in the journalistic process. NPR's WHYY has lost at least half its journalists. Many - Inquirer.com Six months ago, our team from Temple Universitys Klein College of Media and Communication released a diversity and inclusion audit of the Inquirer which shared a series of recommendations around sourcing, editing, community engagement and workplace culture. Get the Poynter newsletter that's right for you. Laura went to Emory University in Atlanta, where she studied English literature and was a member of the Delta Delta Delta sorority. Nearly two years and several extraordinary measures later, they identified 33 of the 43 people who had set off from West Africa. Established in 1829, it is considered a trustworthy source of information. Although hyperlocal, niche outlets have the potential to address some of the ensuing gaps, these are often relatively under-resourced news organizations, raising questions about their long-term sustainability. To adjust for less than perfect precision and recall, we follow Stryker et al.s method of using recall and precision rates to produce a coefficient to apply to the number of COVID-19 (multiplied by coefficient of 1.07) and crime stories (multiplied by coefficient of 1.05) surfaced by our searches to produce an estimated total number of stories in each category of coverage for each outlet during our search period. Assessing differences in formats, we find that digital-only outlets, several of which are newer entrants in the citys media system (e.g., Billy Penn, Passyunk Post, and West Philly Local), do not appear to be significantly altering the systems socioeconomic dynamics (RQ2). For instance, in terms of what Galtung and Ruge call frequency, individual crimes occur often, though they typically are of a short term nature, while the pandemic continues to unfold over a long time period, though with frequent events relevant to most, if not all of Friedland et al.s critical information needs. She is survived by Mr. Cianfranis daughters and grandchildren. But after Hurricane Katrina devastated New Orleans in 2005, she, along with her father and her pets, moved back to Memphis. Inquirer.com: Philadelphia local news, sports, jobs, cars, homes In Wildwood, the mayor and a commissioner won't resign despite indictments. Ms. Foreman with her father, Wilmer L. Foreman, who had also worked as a journalist. Inquirerhas made changed its coverage of race, after a year-long review of its practices. Nonprofit and publicly funded forms of ownership reduce profit pressures but sustaining these revenue modelsparticularly in the United States where public funding is relatively lowoften requires additional funding streams. A lot remains to be done and there are likely challenges ahead that we cant anticipate, Hughes says. The Author(s) 2022. Staff expressed concerns that the demands of productivity metrics meant it was difficult to take time to develop a more diverse spectrum of sources, or to pause to have reflexive conversations with editors about how communities are represented in their coverage. But she was among the first to have that romance, with a powerful politician, blow up into a public scandal. After its infamous Buildings Matter, Too headline, the paper launched its Inquirer for All project to rebuild to be inclusive and antiracist. Conflict of interest: The authors declared the following potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article: Timothy Neffs and Pawel Popiel's postdoctoral research fellowships were supported, in part, by the Independence Public Media Foundation. A key need identified in our original audit was the importance of increasing the representation of BIPOC journalists in leadership roles and on key desks which lacked representation. Additionally, though we argue that during the pandemic a broader range of critical information needs are met by COVID coverage than by coverage of individual crime events, we acknowledge that the importance of COVID news versus crime news is an open question. Significant transformation will mean pushing beyond the Inquirer for All as a project, and integrating its efforts into the ongoing work of journalism at the Inquirer. Median or average weighted median HHI used for most outlets, with exceptions of average HHI for Chestnut Hill Local; Jewish Exponent; Philadelphia Business Journal; Philadelphia Daily News; Philadelphia Inquirer; Philadelphia Magazine. If the Inquirer is to avoid these pitfalls, it must grapple with some of journalisms existential questions along the way namely who is its journalism for, how to pay for it, and what values guide it. These include, among other things, creating a community desk, developing community engagement goals for performance reviews, creating a community advisory council, and holding accountability conversations with external community stakeholders. Analysis of random subsamples of stories shows that COVID and crime items in the Tribune often are wire service stories that raise racial justice concerns, and the Tribunes COVID-to-crime coverage ratio may be higher than indicated in Table3. Newsrooms attempting similar work would do well to consider a few lessons from the Inquirers experiences: A common critique of many DEI initiatives is that they tend to get stuck at the level of a project and fall short of institutional transformation. While managers affirmed that taking the time needed to follow antiracist practices was a priority, resource pressures were ever-present. Laura Foreman, a reporter for The Philadelphia Inquirer in the 1970s, was surely not the first journalist to become romantically involved with a source. Hughes, publisher-CEO of thePhiladelphia Inquirer. Given the structural nature of both the journalism crisis and the citys historic inequalities, news gaps may persist, which may call for more significant policy interventions and experimentations with new models of media ownership and governance. As explained by Stryker et al. Explore the The Philadelphia Inquirer online newspaper archive. We are pro-democracy, he said. (2006) to develop and validate search term strings that demonstrate high levels of precision in surfacing this coverage. For our content analysis generating ratios of COVID-19 coverage to crime coverage, we follow the rigorous method outlined by Stryker et al. Sourcing and editing practices that catered to an imaginary print reader were at least partially to blame. Age indices above 100 indicate a higher percentage of people over 35 or higher median age than found in Philadelphia as a whole (34.7 median age; adding or subtracting 1 for each percentage point over or under citywide percentage, or for each year, in the case of median ages). With the collapse of the advertising business model, the Inquirer, like numerous other U.S. newspapers, is trying to do more with less. Most nonprofits give proportionally low attention to crime, though the Inquirer, which has a hybrid ownership structure as a public-benefit corporation owned by a nonprofit, is near the weighted system average (ratio of 2.8) and its Daily News edition is below the average (2.4). In subsequent years, the press used euphemisms like enhanced interrogation techniques when they should have said torture. Or they called suspected terrorists at Guantnamo Bay detainees, as if they were being sent to the principals office rather than serving what amounted to a prison term of many years. Confronting the misinformation society, Uneasy peace: The great crime decline, the renewal of city life, and the next war of violence, Validation of database search terms for content analysis: The case of cancer news coverage, Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly, Presentation and impact of market-driven journalism on sensationalism in global TV news, Community-centered journalism: Engaging people, exploring solutions, and building trust, Sourcing diversity, shifting culture: Building cultural competence in public media, Communication, class and concentric media practices: Developing a contemporary rubric. With the exception of magazine-style outlets attracting affluent audiences (e.g., Philadelphia Business Journal, Philadelphia Magazine, and Philadelphia Weekly), commercial, privately held outlets tend to show low ratios of COVID-19 to crime coverage. Unlike our assessment of average income, education, and age indices, ratio averages include major commercial TV affiliates, which generally have large audiences but low COVID-to-crime coverage ratios and thus have a systemwide suppression effect on average ratios. under pressure to appear patriotic in the aftermath of the attacks. and is the same edition as the printed copy available at the newsstand. Albk E., van Dalen A., Jebril N., de Vreese C. H. (, Althaus S. L., Cizmar A. M., Gimpel J. G. (, Ardia D, Ringel E, Ekstrand V. S., Fox A. She was a big talent very perceptive, wise about all sorts of things, an excellent writer and an extremely nice and interesting person.. This article was published more than1 year ago. When audience income, education, and age cannot be determined from an outlets media kits, direct communication, or news sources, we use U.S. Census data (American Community Survey) to estimate these data points.